Old Brookville is a picturesque enclave in Oyster Bay, known for its sprawling estates, elegant colonial and contemporary homes, and tree-lined lanes that evoke a timeless countryside charm. This tight-knit community blends serene natural beauty with a spirit of welcome, offering residents privacy, lush green spaces, and a sense of understated sophistication.
Old Brookville offers a peaceful village environment characterized by its calm and quiet atmosphere with minimal traffic noise in most areas. The community features a significant number of single detached homes, many built around the late 1960s, providing ample space with several residences boasting four or more bedrooms. Convenient driving and ample parking make transportation smooth for residents. Local amenities include supermarkets within easy reach of many residences and a selection of restaurants and cafes nearby. Educational needs are met with primary schools accessible locally. Overall, Old Brookville combines spacious housing and a tranquil setting in a welcoming community atmosphere.
Home buyers who prefer a relaxed environment will enjoy Old Brookville. Old Brookville is reasonably quiet overall, as the streets tend to be peaceful - although that is not the case near the railway line.
Parks, schools, dining, and what makes this neighborhood special
Located on Hegemans Lane, Youngs Farm has been a local institution since 1893, known for its charming farmstand, fresh produce, homemade baked goods, and picturesque rural setting that captures the village’s agricultural heritage.
Situated on Glen Cove Avenue, North Shore High School is renowned for its International Baccalaureate program and serves as a pillar of excellence in education for families in Old Brookville and surrounding communities.
Nestled just minutes away on Glen Head Road, The Rustic Root is a beloved local eatery for Old Brookville residents, boasting farm-to-table dishes, cozy decor, and a strong focus on locally-sourced ingredients.
A convenient neighborhood staple on Northern Boulevard, Brookville Country Market offers gourmet foods, fresh coffee, baked goods, and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for daily essentials or quick bites.
Running through the heart of the village, the Brookville Greenbelt Trail offers scenic pathways for walking and biking, showcasing the area’s mature trees, rolling landscapes, and tranquil suburban beauty.
Things to do, events, and what's happening this month
A weekly farmers market offering fresh local produce, baked goods, flowers and more—great for Old Brookville residents looking to support nearby growers and enjoy community atmosphere.
An evening gospel/concert performance by Son Stone in a local gallery—ideal for families and residents wanting a cultural outing close to home.
A tribute musical performance appealing to fans of classic singer-songwriters, conveniently located in Brookville for a short trip from Old Brookville.
A classical chamber music concert offering a refined, accessible cultural experience within a few minutes’ drive—perfect for music lovers and families.
An engaging performance featuring sarod music—a chance for Old Brookville residents to experience world music just down the road.
Stories, updates, and things to know in Old Brookville
Local characteristics and demographics for Old Brookville
